Goodfella's Pizzeria

If you're in the Afton, OK area and craving authentic Italian flavors, Goodfella's Pizzeria is a must-visit destination. Nestled at 450677 OK-85, this charming establishment offers a delightful pizza experience that has earned rave reviews from locals and visitors alike.

Many patrons, like Heather Caraway, appreciate the variety, particularly the availability of gluten-free options, while simultaneously noting that the quality justifies the slightly higher prices. Regulars such as Dave McCrorey and Josef Hobson laud not only the delicious pizza but also the welcoming nature of the staff and owners, creating an inviting atmosphere for everyone.

The menu is packed with choices—from savory calzones to an array of fresh toppings, and as Emma Hayes points out, the crust is simply perfection. Whether you're stopping by after work or making a special trip, Jason D insists this gem outshines any other pizza venue in Tulsa. All in all, Goodfella's Pizzeria is more than just a restaurant; it’s a community hub that serves up comfort and satisfaction in every bite.